Creamy Seafood Stuffed Shells Recipe

There’s something so indulgent yet comforting about seafood-stuffed pasta shells. When you combine the creamy richness of the filling with the briny freshness of shrimp, lobster, and crab, you get a perfect balance of flavors that makes you feel like you’re dining at a coastal restaurant, all while being cozied up at home. This recipe for Creamy Seafood Stuffed Shells has become a go-to for me when I want to impress my dinner guests—or just treat myself on a Sunday evening! It’s one of those dishes where every bite feels like a little celebration.

One of the things I love about this recipe is how adaptable it is. Whether you’re using fresh seafood or making it a more budget-friendly weeknight meal by subbing in alternatives, it’s a forgiving dish that never fails to deliver. And that creamy sauce? It’s the kind you want to dip a piece of bread in, long after you’ve finished the pasta. So, let’s get started, because I’m already hungry!

this RECIPE

That one dinner party moment…

I remember the first time I made this dish; it was for a small dinner gathering with friends. I had just moved into a new place, and this was my unofficial “housewarming.” Now, I’ll be the first to admit that I may have been a little too ambitious that night. I was juggling appetizers, a salad, and of course, this recipe, which at the time felt like a bit of a challenge. I was sweating over the stove (because, of course, the air conditioner wasn’t working properly), frantically stirring the sauce while trying to stuff the shells at the same time. Let’s just say, I may have overcooked the pasta that time. But guess what? Even with slightly-too-soft shells, everyone raved about the dish. The creamy filling and tender seafood saved the day. And, of course, I’ve perfected the timing since then!

A quick dive into the dish’s background

Stuffed shells are rooted in Italian cuisine, with variations found across many regions of Italy. Traditionally, they’re filled with ricotta, spinach, and often ground meat. This seafood twist feels like a nod to coastal regions where seafood is abundant and beloved. Combining pasta with seafood might sound luxurious, but it’s actually a pretty common practice in Southern Italy, particularly in places like Sicily, where seafood is central to the culinary tradition. Over time, recipes like this one have evolved to incorporate creamy sauces and rich cheeses, making it a popular choice for celebrations or when you just want to impress someone with your cooking skills!

Let’s talk ingredients: the stars of the show

Shrimp, lobster, and crab

The trio of shrimp, lobster, and crab is the heart of the filling. Shrimp brings a juicy, slightly sweet bite, while lobster adds a rich, buttery depth. Crab rounds it out with its soft, delicate texture. If you’re not a fan of lobster or looking to cut costs, feel free to use only shrimp and crab. Or, swap in scallops for a nice change of pace. When picking seafood, fresh is always best, but if you’re working with frozen, just ensure it’s fully thawed and drained well.

Cream cheese

The cream cheese is what makes the filling so decadently creamy. It holds everything together and adds that rich, tangy flavor. If you’re looking to lighten things up, you can use a reduced-fat cream cheese, though I wouldn’t skimp here—it’s worth the indulgence.

Spinach

Spinach adds a pop of color and a bit of freshness to balance out the richness. If fresh spinach isn’t available, frozen spinach works great—just make sure to thaw and drain it thoroughly to avoid a soggy filling. You could even experiment with other greens like kale if you’re feeling adventurous!

Parmesan Reggiano and mozzarella

These cheeses melt beautifully, adding both flavor and texture. Parmesan brings that sharp, nutty taste, while mozzarella gives the filling its stretchy, gooey quality. If you’re out of Parmesan, Pecorino Romano works in a pinch, though it’s slightly saltier, so adjust seasoning accordingly.

Kitchen gear: What you need (and what you can totally skip)

For this recipe, the essentials are fairly simple, but there are a few key tools that can make the process smoother:

• A large skillet: You’ll need this for making the sauce and cooking the seafood. I recommend non-stick if you’ve got it, but any good-quality skillet will do.
• A 9×13 baking dish: This is where your shells will bake to perfection. Glass or ceramic is best because it distributes heat evenly.
• A good whisk: When making the sauce, a whisk will help you avoid any lumps from the flour and keep it nice and smooth.
• Tongs or a slotted spoon: For fishing the shrimp and lobster out of the skillet.
• Foil: Don’t forget to cover the dish with foil while baking. It keeps the moisture in, so your shells don’t dry out.

Step-by-step: My foolproof method (and a few hard-learned lessons)

1. Prep your pasta shells
   Boil the shells until they’re just shy of al dente (about 2 minutes less than the package suggests). You don’t want them to be too soft since they’ll cook further in the oven. And trust me—cooled, undercooked shells are a LOT easier to stuff without tearing.
2. Whip up that dreamy cream sauce
   In a skillet, melt a tablespoon of butter, then whisk in the flour until it’s thick and bubbly. Slowly pour in the heavy cream, almond milk, and white wine, whisking constantly to avoid lumps. Once it’s smooth, add in the garlic, Parmesan, and Italian seasoning. Taste as you go—I’m guilty of adding a little more Parmesan than the recipe calls for because, let’s face it, there’s no such thing as too much cheese.
3. Cook the seafood
   Heat the remaining butter in the same skillet, then toss in the shrimp and lobster. A few minutes on each side should do the trick. You’re looking for them to turn opaque. Don’t overcook them—they’ll finish in the oven!
4. Mix up the filling
   In a large bowl, combine the cooked seafood, cream cheese, spinach, half the mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Parmesan. Add Old Bay seasoning (because we want that zesty flavor!) and adjust the salt and pepper to taste. This is the part where you can get creative—taste the mixture and adjust as needed.
5. Assemble and bake
   Spoon the seafood mixture into each shell (around 1 ½ to 2 tablespoons per shell). Arrange them in the baking dish over your sauce, then sprinkle the remaining mozzarella on top. Cover with foil and bake for 20 minutes. Remove the foil, and bake for an additional 5-10 minutes to get that golden, bubbly cheese topping.

Variations on a theme

• Gluten-free: Use gluten-free pasta shells and swap the flour in the sauce for a gluten-free alternative.
• Dairy-free: Opt for dairy-free cream cheese and mozzarella. Almond milk is already used in this recipe, so you’re halfway there!
• Vegan option: Try a plant-based seafood substitute (they exist!) and use vegan cheeses. For the sauce, stick to plant-based milk and butter.
• Seasonal: Swap spinach for other seasonal greens like arugula in the spring or even kale in the winter.

Serving and presentation ideas

For a beautiful presentation, garnish with a sprinkle of fresh parsley or a light dusting of paprika for color. Serve these shells alongside a crisp, green salad and perhaps some toasted garlic bread to soak up that creamy sauce. You could even add a few lemon wedges on the side for a burst of acidity that cuts through the richness.

Drink pairings

I’m a big fan of pairing seafood with white wine, and since we’re already using Pinot Grigio in the recipe, it’s the perfect complement to the meal. You could also go with a Chardonnay if you prefer something a bit richer. For a non-alcoholic option, sparkling water with a lemon twist works wonderfully.

Storing and reheating tips

If you have leftovers (though they’re so delicious, it’s hard to believe you will!), store them in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days. Reheat in the oven at 350°F, covered with foil, until warmed through. For quicker reheating, the microwave works too, though the shells might be a bit softer.

Adjusting for different serving sizes

This recipe makes enough to serve 4-6 people, but if you’re cooking for just two, simply halve the recipe. On the flip side, if you’re hosting a larger group, you can easily double it. Just make sure to use two baking dishes, so the shells aren’t overcrowded.

Common issues (and how to fix them!)

• Overcooked seafood: Keep a close eye while cooking shrimp and lobster; they cook quickly and will turn rubbery if overdone. They should be opaque and firm, but not tough.
• Runny filling: If the filling feels too wet, add more cheese or a handful of breadcrumbs to bind it together.

Ready to dive into creamy, seafood heaven?

I hope you’re as excited to try these creamy seafood stuffed shells as I am to share the recipe! Feel free to put your own spin on it—I’d love to hear how it turns out for you. It’s one of those dishes that never fails to impress, and I promise, it’s easier than it looks. Bon appétit!

FAQs:

1. Can I make this recipe ahead of time?
   Absolutely! You can assemble the shells and store them in the fridge overnight. Just bake them fresh before serving.
2. What can I use instead of wine in the sauce?
   You can substitute wine with chicken or vegetable broth for a non-alcoholic option.
3. Can I freeze the leftovers?
   Yes! Store them in an airtight container, and they’ll keep for up to 2 months. Reheat in the oven for best results.
4. Is there a good substitute for cream cheese?
   Ricotta cheese can work in place of cream cheese for a lighter, fluffier filling.
5. What side dishes go well with seafood stuffed shells?
   A fresh garden salad, garlic bread, or roasted vegetables like asparagus pair wonderfully with this dish.

Print